Pros:
Low Initial Cost: Significantly cheaper upfront per bulb than LED equivalents.
Warm, Familiar Light: True incandescent spectrum with excellent color rendering (CRI ~100) and a warm color temperature (typically 2700K-3000K).
Electrically Simple: Resistive load; no complex driver required. Operate directly on low-voltage AC or DC.
Compatibility: Work with existing fixtures and circuits designed for incandescent loads without issue.
Dimming: Naturally and perfectly compatible with all standard dimmers.
No EMI/RFI: Produce minimal electromagnetic or radio frequency interference.
Cons:
Very Low Efficiency/High Heat: ~90% of energy is wasted as heat (typically 1-3 lumens per watt). This can be a fire risk in enclosed spaces and is costly to run continuously.
Extremely Short Lifespan: Average life is only 1,000-2,000 hours. Frequent replacement is needed, especially in critical signal applications.
Fragility: Filament is sensitive to vibration and shock, leading to premature failure.
High Long-Term Cost: Despite low unit cost, energy and replacement labor costs over time are very high.
Limited Color Options: Colored signals require filters (which can fade/burn) or colored glass bulbs.
Obsolescence: Many regions are phasing out incandescent technology due to energy regulations.
Pros:
High Efficiency/Low Heat: Typically 80-100+ lumens per watt. Drastically reduces energy consumption (often 85-90% less) and operating costs. Minimal heat output improves safety and reduces thermal stress on fixtures.
Extremely Long Lifespan: Rated for 25,000 to 50,000+ hours, reducing maintenance frequency and long-term replacement costs.
Ruggedness: Solid-state construction is highly resistant to vibration and shock.
Design Flexibility: Available in a wide range of colors (single-color or RGB), color temperatures, and beam angles. Can incorporate smart features.
Directional Light: LEDs are naturally directional, ideal for indicator and signal applications.
Cool Operation: Can be used in thermally sensitive environments or enclosed fixtures.
Cons:
Higher Unit Cost: Initial purchase price is 3-10x that of an incandescent bulb.
Driver/Compatibility Issues: May require current-limiting resistors or constant-current drivers. Some may not dim smoothly or at all with legacy dimmers.
Electrical Noise: Poorly designed LED circuits can generate electromagnetic interference (EMI), problematic in sensitive electronic environments (e.g., radio, avionics, industrial control panels).
Heat Sensitivity: While they run cool, the LED chip itself is sensitive to high junction temperatures; poor thermal design in a tiny E10 base can lead to accelerated lumen depreciation and shortened life.
Potential for Flicker: Low-quality drivers can cause visible or stroboscopic flicker, unsuitable for some signaling or moving equipment applications.
Color Spectrum: Some cheaper LEDs have poor color rendering (though not critical for most signal applications). The light quality can differ from the "warm" incandescent glow.
For New Installations or Retrofit Where Reliability & Efficiency Matter: LED is the clear choice. The long-term savings on energy and maintenance almost always justify the higher initial cost. This is especially true for hard-to-access panels, continuous operation (e.g., exit signs, panel indicators), or battery-powered systems.
For Legacy Systems, Harsh EMI Environments, or Simple Dimming: Incandescent may still be necessary. This is critical in certain aviation, marine, or vintage railroad signaling where system voltage spikes, wide temperature ranges, and EMI certification are concerns. Some legacy control panels and dimming circuits may only work reliably with resistive incandescent loads.
For Aesthetic/Hobbyist Use (Model Railroads, Vintage Cars): Incandescent is sometimes preferred for its authentic warm glow and dimming behavior. However, high-quality warm-white LEDs are now often indistinguishable.
The transition from incandescent to LED for miniature signal lamps mirrors the broader lighting trend. For the vast majority of commercial, industrial, and consumer applications, LED equivalents are superior due to dramatic efficiency, longevity, and reliability gains. However, the miniature incandescent E10 lamp retains niche applications where its simplicity, pure resistive load, and specific light quality are non-negotiable. Always verify the electrical compatibility (voltage, current, dimming, EMI) of an LED replacement within the specific system, especially in safety-critical or legacy equipment.
One more step before you proceed...